Motherwell have been fined £5,000 by the Scottish FA for criticising a VAR decision that swung a crucial Premiership match against Celtic in May. The club, sitting fourth with 54 points from 33 games, now plans to consult solicitors over the disciplinary outcome.
What happened at the hearing?
The SFA charged Motherwell and midfielder Elliot Watt for comments implying bias or incompetence by match officials. Watt, who called the decision the worst VAR call in history, received a four-match ban after admitting the charge. The club described themselves as extremely disappointed with the outcome and requested written reasons before deciding on further steps.
The incident stems from a stoppage-time penalty awarded to Celtic at Fir Park on the final day of the 2025-26 season. That decision, later defended by SFA head of referees Willie Collum, played a key role in the title race with Hearts leading by 16 points. Motherwell’s recent form has slumped, with three losses in their last five games including a 4-0 defeat to Aarhus on 5 July.
Why it matters for Motherwell
The fine and Watt’s suspension add to a difficult summer for the Steelmen. With 52 goals scored and 29 conceded, their +23 goal difference ranks mid-table despite the recent dip. Their next fixture on 17 July against Genk at home offers a chance to reset after the VAR controversy overshadowed their preparations.
Legal action would mark a rare escalation in Scottish football’s disciplinary disputes. Clubs usually accept punishments to avoid further sanctions, but Motherwell’s statement signals a willingness to challenge the decision. The club’s stance could influence how future VAR-related complaints are handled.
What comes next?
Motherwell will review the written reasons from the SFA before deciding whether to appeal. Watt’s ban means he will miss at least four league matches, leaving a gap in midfield during a critical pre-season period. The club’s focus now shifts to the Genk tie and the challenge of closing the 16-point gap to league leaders Hearts.
The VAR storm may not be over. If Motherwell pursue legal avenues, the case could set a precedent for how clubs respond to refereeing decisions in future campaigns.
